Vocation Without Collapse: Motherhood & Academia
Editor's Note: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Regent University, its faculty, administration, or affiliates.
As a Christian wife and mother in academia, I’ve been asked, “How do you do it?” The honest answer is less impressive than people hope: sometimes I don’t. Sometimes I get a migraine and need to lie down. Sometimes I disappoint someone. Sometimes excellence means stopping. When that moment arrives, the temptation is to assume failure. Yet the deeper issue is often disordered love.
Every Christian is called to a vocation. To form a right-oriented, layered, vocational life takes setting boundaries and seeing human limits as a gift. Early in my career, I could feel the walls closing in. There was so much to do that I didn’t know where to start. Being tasked to teach, serve, and contribute to scholarly work is a serious responsibility; if I could not bring my intellect before the Lord, my teaching would lack integrity. Professional competence is part of the vocation itself, as John Paul II (1984) told Catholic educators, “You are called to bring professional competence and a high standard of excellence to your teaching.”
Further, the Summa Theologiae of St. Thomas Aquinas beautifully states the order of charity (Aquinas, 1920, II-II, q. 26). Simplified, it goes like this: God first, then self and neighbor. When I looked honestly at my life, I could see where that order had slipped. If God is to be my first love, how does that change the way my days play out? If I learn to love myself properly, as God intends, how does that change the way I care for my neighbors? And as a spouse and parent, my most important neighbors live in my own home. First Timothy 5:8 says, “If any one does not provide for his relatives, and especially for his own family, he has disowned the faith and is worse than an unbeliever” (Revised Standard Version Catholic Edition).
After my first year as an assistant professor, I knew I needed to examine my life and make decisions that supported my worldview. How could I be a faithful employee with a wonderful institutional mission to fulfill, take care of my children, spend time with my husband, properly care for myself, and live a life oriented toward my love of God? It seemed impossible. But our God is one who hears and answers prayers. Three lessons reshaped my understanding of vocation: peace begins with asking a different question, limits are a gift, and excellence requires detachment.
The Beginning of Peace
During my doctoral years, I attempted to balance full-time work, advanced study, and motherhood. When I moved into a full-time faculty role, the administrative and accreditation demands intensified the pressure to prove myself. Faculty life includes not only writing and teaching but also administrative stewardship. I had long promised myself that if given the opportunity, I would serve those responsibilities without complaint. That commitment did not make the work easy.
However, as my first year as a faculty member ended, I could look back on what I had done and recognize, through God’s gracious mercy and strength, that it was enough. I began to ask a different question. Not “Did I do everything I thought I should do?” but “Did I fulfill what was required of me in this season?” The difference between those questions was the beginning of peace.
The Gift of Limitations
What I learned through that experience was the importance of looking back to move forward more lightly. Quantifying what I had accomplished, what was required of me, and what was necessary to fulfill my contract with excellence relieved a significant mental burden. I even used digital tools to list my responsibilities, compare them with tenure expectations, and discern which tasks I could reasonably release. I stopped trying to do everything that every wise mentor suggested. I didn’t accept every invitation. I couldn’t be on seven committees, travel monthly to conferences, and take on additional projects if I were to be faithful with my assigned work and have anything left to give my family.
God created us with limitations, and those can be gifts in their own way. Remembering where the job ends frees up energy to engage faithfully with family and outside commitments. It can be humbling when we feel like we should be able to do it all. But leaning into humility is a good thing. It’s a virtue. Likewise, it’s difficult for some to learn that “no” is a complete sentence. People-pleasing can masquerade as charity, but in reality, it often stems from fear rather than love.
Detachment
It is a good thing to want to complete tasks with excellence. But excellence has limits within the framework of rightly ordered loves. A beautiful complement to the virtue of humility is poverty of spirit.
Poverty of spirit is not about incompetence but about detachment. It’s the freedom to receive or relinquish success without losing oneself. Happy are those who are detached from worldly things (wealth, success, physical beauty) and instead are empty enough to receive God (Matthew 5:3). In other words, those who are rightly ordered. When we want what God wants, the rest falls away. To quote one of my favorite teachers of our time, Bishop Robert Barron, “Don’t ask for wealth, don’t ask for beauty, don’t ask for health, don’t ask for power. Instead, ask to understand your life from the standpoint of God” (Barron, 2024). When we are rightly ordered, we will know what to do if we get the positive performance review or promotion. Or if we don’t. We will know how to proceed and glorify God. That’s the detachment I’m talking about: living a life that’s fully surrendered to God.
The next time someone asks me, “How do you do it all?” I want to point them to my highest love: God. Our help is in the name of the Lord (Psalm 124:8). It is by the grace of God that I have been given these roles, and by his grace that I will do his will for my life.
References
Aquinas, T. (1920). The Summa theologiae of St. Thomas Aquinas (2nd and rev. ed., Fathers of the English Dominican Province, Trans.). New Advent. https://www.newadvent.org/summa/3026.htm (Original work published ca. 1265–1274)
Barron, R. (2024, October 12). What do you ask God for? – Bishop Barron’s Sunday sermon [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rCh9aTs_uw
John Paul II. (1984, September 12). Address to Catholic educators [Speech transcript]. The Holy See. https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/speeches/1984/september/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe_19840912_educatori-cattolici.html
Revised Standard Version Bible, Catholic edition. (2006). Ignatius Press. (Original work published 1966)
Rombs, A. A. R. (2026, April 17). Vocation without collapse [Conference presentation]. Regent University School of Education Symposium, Virtual.
